This is a post I knew I would have to get to at some
point, and now I’m nervous about writing it.
I’ve been thinking about it for a while now, hoping that some epiphany
would come to me.
How am I going to approach it?
How will it be received?
Can I even do the subject justice?
Will I sound like an ignorant fool?
In the end, I suppose I have to trust my gut, be as
honest as I can, and hope for the best.
And damn it, this blog is my forum
(as insignificant as it might be). I’m
not forcing my opinions or notions on anyone. I’m not spraying it on Facebook
like some pissed off barn cat. But I
feel strongly enough about it that I want to address it. It’s relevant to my little story here, and
most of all, it’s relevant to my girls—the girls I’ve grown to love with
everything I have and then some.
As a kid in the 80’s, I freaking LOVED Diff’rent
Strokes. I mean, who didn’t? Arnold, Willis, Mallory, Mr. Drummond, Mrs.
Garrett…and the lady after Mrs. Garrett went to live with the girls of The
Facts of Life. You know, to teach them
about right and wrong and their menstrual cycles.
Pearl.
Yes. That’s who it was. Pearl.
Diff’rent Strokes was so popular that other networks
were combing the country in search of their slice of the stunted black kid pie.
Because it was comedy gold.
Soon thereafter came Webster, (which in my opinion was
inferior to Diff’rent Strokes, but still good), the story of the little orphan
boy who went to live with George (Mongo like candy!) and Kathrine (Ma’am)
Papadapolis. I remember that Webster had little secret passageways around the
house, most notably behind the grandfather clock.
God, how I wanted a secret passageway. I remember how I’d keep hoping that our
suburban ranch house had one hidden somewhere and that I just hadn’t found
yet. I’m sure I looked behind our
grandfather clock at least a million times to find it.
Anyway, the popularity of these shows was undeniable. America fell in love with the notion of poor
little orphaned black kids being hilariously raised by white people. I suppose in some ways, it was a step forward
from the decidedly segregated sitcoms such as All In The Family and The
Jeffersons.
American TV was breaking down racial barriers, one
funny little black kid with an inoffensive birth defect at a time.
The similarities between our situation and those 80’s
sitcoms are pretty obvious. And when
they first moved in, I thought, “hey, kinda like Diff’rent Strokes!” I knew we’d have tons of hilarious
misadventures (as long as everyone stays away from the bike shop…if you’ve seen
the show, you know what I’m talking about).
Hell, we even had the older one who was very intelligent and much more
reserved, and the younger one who spoke with a slight lisp and said the most
out-raaageous things!
I’m living an
80’s sitcom!
And most of the time…yeah, it is a little like
that. There are a lot of funny moments
worthy of canned laughter (if you’ve been keeping up with this blog, you might
already know this, or else why in the hell are you still reading), heart-wrenching
moments where the audience is uncomfortably silent, and touching moments worthy
of drawn out “awwwwwws.” We are different
from other families in town, and that’s something in which we pride
ourselves.
And ready for it or not, we found a new perspective.
The girls had shown up with the social worker that
very first day with only with the filthy clothes on their backs and a single
stuffed animal each. Their shoes were
falling off their feet, their legs and arms were covered in bed bug bites, and
they smelled awful, like sweat and urine.
They were not what I had expected to come walking
through our door. I had expected cute
little…well…I guess in my mind’s eye…white…kids. I didn’t really know why I thought this. It wasn’t like they told us that only white
kids would be placed in our home. In
fact, they told us it was far more likely that an African American or Hispanic
child would be here.
But I still pictured
white kids.
And when they showed up, scared, shabby, and dark
skinned, I just thought: Oh.
Huh. Ooookaaaay…and a general
feeling of doubt began to rise in my heart.
Like when a Christmas present isn’t quite what you had pictured it, even
though you never really realized you had pictured it at all.
I’ve never said that out loud or even wanted to admit
it to myself. But as I said before, I’m
laying it out there. Because it’s too
important not to be completely
honest. And not just with you who may be reading this, but with myself. It’s the first step. But I’ll get to that later.
So the first thing we did was take them to Wal-Mart to
gather some quick clothes. Not my first
choice for apparel, but it was an emergency.
They had to have something.
I remember thinking, we’ll have to get them some decent clothes ASAP. Because where
we grew up, if you wore clothes from Wal-Mart, you were gonna get made fun of.
As we drove in silence to the store, the car filling
up with the unkempt reek that clung to their clothes, I was having doubts. Would I be able to do this? Was I ready for these challenges?
Can I love these kids?
When we got out of the car and began heading into the
store, I felt a little hand tentatively grab my pinky. I looked down and Mo was staring up at me,
her large, brown eyes shimmering there in the dark beneath the street lights,
wondering if it was okay to hold my hand.
When I looked down she pulled away and shied, as if she had maybe done
something wrong.
I said, “It’s okay, you can hold my hand if you want.”
And she smiled at me.
And I smiled back.
And we held hands through the parking lot into the
store, with her fingers occasionally tightening around mine.
Inside the store, we perused the aisles. The girls were pretty giddy to be getting new
clothes, taking cheap Hello Kitty tee shirts off the rack and twirling around
with them, like twin brides to be with new wedding dresses. Amy and I had to check the tags (those that
were still there) on the clothes they were wearing to see their sizes. We had no idea. I joked that Amy should just get them her
sizes, because she wasn’t much bigger.
Amy shot me a look of mock disgust, but then giggled. Like always.
But we were both tense.
After we had gathered a cart load of shirts, jeans,
jackets, sweatshirts, underwear, socks, a few toys, we went to the dressing
rooms. A middle aged white woman,
bespectacled and strange, watched us intently as we ushered the girls into the
rooms. While Amy was in there with them,
the woman looked at me and said, “They yours?”
This is a question we had been prepared for by the agency, and we had
canned answers prepared. Most people are
obviously curious, mean well, but don’t know how to ask tactfully. At least she waited until the girls weren’t
right there with us.
“Well,” I said, “kind of. For now.
They’re foster kids. They were
placed with us just this evening.”
“Oh! That’s
great. Congratulations to you.”
“Uh…thanks.”
“You know, I’ve thought
about being a foster parent a lot of times, but…you know.”
“Yeah. I’m sure
it’s going to be tough.”
“And plus, my husband, well, he’s got a temper, so…”
“Uh huh.
Probably not the best then.”
Jesus.
She went back to folding clothes and I stood there
thinking a bit.
A few minutes went by, and from behind the slatted
door beneath which I could see a jumble of feet and clothes, I heard Amy say,
“Okay, go show Matt.”
The door swung open, and Shay came out wearing a new
shirt and jeans. She smiled impishly and
tugged at the shirt tail, shifting her weight back and forth upon her bare
feet.
“Do you like it, Daddy?”
Daddy. Wasn’t
ready for that. My brain said, little soon for that, isn’t it? But I
shook that voice from my head and said, “Yeah, Shay, I like it a lot. Do you?”
“Yes!”
“Okay then.
Does it fit?”
“Yes!”
“Okay then.
Alright, go back in and try some other things on. We’ll have a fashion show.”
“Okay!”
She waddled back into the little room, closed the door
behind her, and she said “He likes them!”
Amy said, “Okay!
We’ll get them then.”
From behind me I heard someone say, “awww.” I turned and saw a large black man in his mid
twenties standing there, grinning. He
was wearing baggy pants, baggy shirt, and a pristinely white cap with a perfectly
straight brim. His teeth glinted in the store
light. He was wearing a grill.
I smiled, nodded quickly, and turned away. Looking back on it, that’s how I’d always
reacted to that situation. I’d
acknowledge the presence, then separate myself.
“You’re doing a good thing,” the man said.
I turned back around and looked at him. He wasn’t mad, he wasn’t being sarcastic, he
wasn’t being anything but genuine.
“What’s that?” I asked.
“I said, y’all are doing a good thing.” It was then I saw the others behind him,
presumably his family, a wife and a little boy, standing there as well.
Where had they come from?
The woman was smiling too. The kid just stared at me with his mouth
open.
I smiled, nodded again, and turned back around.
The girls came out periodically, showing off their
clothes and laughing. Eventually, they
were finished. They had their old
clothes back on. Amy handed the weird
lady at the counter the clothes that hadn’t fit, and as we ushered the kids
past the family behind us, the man said, “you girls sure looked nice in all
your new clothes! Bet you can’t wait to
wear them, can you?”
The girls smiled sheepishly, holding their shoulders
up around their ears.
“Okay, girls, let’s go,” I said. As we continued past, the two adults were
still smiling at us and the little boy was still staring.
“Have a good night,” the man said.
“Yeah, you too,” I replied.
This kind of thing happened a lot over the next few
months, and still does. In the grocery
store, in the park, wherever. We notice
black families noticing us. We get a lot
of smiles. We smile back. We talk to them. Only every so often do we get a sideways
glance from a black family, perhaps wondering what in the world these two cute
little kids are doing with these white folks.
But that’s very, very rare.
I want to reiterate…we notice more black families, and we notice more smiles.
Were they always there and we just never saw? Did we always simply acknowledge their
presence and quickly step aside, smiling broadly but never making eye contact,
trying to distance ourselves?
Did we really do
that?
I would imagine it’s a two way street. I would imagine that before we had the girls
in tow they would glance up at us and us at them, then unconsciously avoid one
another.
But who can avoid an 80’s sitcom coming down the
cereal aisle?
White people grin at us as well, take time to talk to
the girls. And everyone, black or white
or other, asks their strange questions that now just slide off our backs.
Are they yours?
Did you adopt?
Do you have any real
kids?
The girls get it at school and daycare as well, but
their responses are always so much more straight forward.
“Are those your parents?”
“Yes.”
“But…they’re white.”
“So?”
There are a lot of mixed families in our
neighborhood. Our neighbors (the family
to which the little towhead boy whom Mo is “totally in love with” belongs) has
biological kids, adopted kids and foster kids.
We couldn’t be happier that the girls have a family to play with that
has the same things going on at their house.
They see it as “normal,” and have, to my knowledge, never felt a moment
of embarrassment for their situation.
That family has introduced us to another family who has both bio kids
and adopted kids, and we spent a wonderful Fourth of July with them at a nearby
pond. Where all the kids just got to be
kids. A luxury I have always, always
taken for granted. As the adults sat on
the deck, we talked about these very issues.
The host family shared with us an experience they had. The kids (an older biological child and at
least one of their adopted Hispanic children) and the dad were out somewhere,
and a person asked the dad, “Where did he (or she, can’t remember) come from?”
The dad replied, “Lubbock.”
The man grinned in a nudge-nudge, wink-wink manner and
said, “I mean, where do they come from?”
It was then that the biological kid said,
“Lubbock! Geez!”
The girls are innocent of the issues of race. I mean, they’re aware their skin is different
from ours, and they don’t pretend to be our biological kids, but they simply
don’t care about it. Never did. And as time has worn on, even in this short
period, I truly think about their skin color less and less. It’s unnerving to me that I ever really
did. I always believed in myself the
bullshit that people tend to say: “I
don’t see color.”
Of course we do.
And I’m coming to grips with my own previous notions, notions that were,
I believed, benign. I mean, I never thought
that all African Americans were gangsters or on welfare or anything terrible
like that. It was never, ever that
obvious.
But that’s the real issue, isn’t it?
I was unwittingly distant from an entire portion of our
American population. Not that it’s my
fault, I wasn’t raised around a lot of African Americans or Hispanics. I enjoyed white privilege my entire life
without ever really knowing it.
It wasn’t that I disliked black people.
I just rarely thought about them at all.
I used to, and to some degree still do, use terms like
“us” and “them.” It’s hard not to. There’s a partition built up in my brain and
it’s hard to break it down and talk around it.
Because it’s engrained in me.
In us. All of
us. Black, white, Hispanic or Asian.
But I’m working on it.
I’m working to understand why I
had this division in my brain. And by acknowledging it, by getting it out
there, even by posting this entry, I’m going to keep self-analyzing and working
to break it down.
Because the girls are innocent of it, and they deserve
to live in a place where “us” and “them” has become just…us.
I’m not naïve enough to think that they won’t lose
their innocence of this matter. One day
someone’s going to sling a terrible word at them and we’ll have talk them
down. And that frightens the hell out of
me.
But because I’m not
black, I won’t know what it’s
like. I can’t relate. All I can do
is love the hell out of them and hold them.
They will never be able to look at me and say, “Dad gets it.” Sure, I’ve been called names before, been
hurt by them before, but as you can tell by the name of this blog, I make light
of it. But I have never experienced that
feeling which just about every minority in this country has felt at some
crushing point in their lives: I cannot expect the same treatment in all things
as my white friends do.
I realize the inflammatory nature of that comment, and
I realize that some of you reading this may feel uncomfortable with that
assertion. Well, quit reading then.
When I voice this fear to some of my friends, they say
well intentioned things like,
“Teach them that it doesn’t matter, that people are
just stupid and that they shouldn’t let it bother them.”
“Teach them not to be a victim.”
“Teach them to ‘rise and overcome.’”
Of course I’ll teach them these things. I’ll teach them that their skin does not
define them, that what is in their heart is the only thing that matters. Because an individual is responsible for their own lot in life.
But should these
words not bother them deeply? Should I
be so dismissive of it?
Should I teach them to distance themselves?
To turn a blind eye to the issues of race in this
country?
Is that responsible parenting?
I’ve seen a lot of terrible traffic on social media
regarding this whole George Zimmerman case.
I’ve gone a few rounds on Facebook over it, mostly colliding with people
who say things like, “it’s over, it’s done, let’s move on.” It’s been bothering
me deeply. Things like,
“Why was this case
such a big deal?”
“Nobody cares when a white kid is killed by black people!”
“The black community is using this as a crutch!”
I’ve tried to gently tell people why it is a big deal, and why this case has
gathered so much traction in the social realm.
Because the implications go far beyond the verdict. I’m no lawyer, but I recently served on a
small jury that was, oddly enough, kind of like this one, where the issue of self
defense was used. It wasn’t racially
charged, just a couple of meatheads fighting in a public place and no one
died. We found the kid not guilty
because the way the law was written and the way it was stated in our jury
instructions. The prosecution couldn’t prove it wasn’t self defense. That was it.
That was our job. So in this
case, again, I don’t know all the ins and outs of it, but I can see why the
jury came to the verdict they did. But I
digress, and all in all, the verdict itself isn’t what’s most important. It,
just like most cases that are racially charged, simply served as a condensation
nucleus for outrage over how an entire population of people feels they are
being treated. That this significant
portion of the population can’t expect the same justice as the rest of the
country. However you feel about that
statement, it cannot be denied that millions upon millions of our neighbors
feel they are being treated like shit by the justice system.
“Al Sharpton is just inciting more racial tension so
he can win an election or get money or something.”
To this I ask:
Is the outrage felt by such a huge population the product of Al
Sharpton, or is Al Sharpton the product of the outrage felt by a huge
population?
Do I really believe that so many people are just whining?
That they secretly want
to keep the issue of racism alive so they can continue to have an excuse to
get “our stuff?”
“Our scholarships?”
“Our grants?”
“Our jobs?”
Or let’s call it what it is…a piece of “our” white
privilege?
I, like many of my friends, and the majority of white
America, whether we knew it or not or want to see it or not, were born on third
and wonder why the hell people can’t hit a triple like we did.
“We” want to
believe we hit that triple.
This is not universal across every individual, and I’m
sure a number of you disagree whole heartedly with what I’m saying and are
poised to come at me with anecdotes of why I’m wrong. Well, save them. This isn’t open for anecdotes. Anecdotes cannot and do not refute the fact
that so many for so long have felt so put down.
Again, whether you believe it to be true or not, the fact is that it is
FELT, and therefore it is real.
The question we must ask: Do I care?
Do I care about my neighbors and friends of color?
Or do I just think there’s no problem and assume
millions of people are just whiners?
That “they” must simply “get over it?”
“Rise and overcome” as an ENTIRE society because of
all the wonderful things “we” have bestowed upon them?
Really?
Even though I will never feel as “they” do…can I at
least acknowledge that there is an issue
here?
Can I TRY to walk a mile in their shoes? Can I at least SEE them as people? As my neighbors? As people I smile at and talk to in the
grocery store? As people I love and care
about?
Can I see them as my children and not as props to some
hilarious ‘80’s sitcom?
If I cannot, then there will always be “we” and
“them.” There will never just be
“us.” The term I want so badly to say
for my girls. I want it to come off my
tongue naturally, without thought, without the notion of separation. There are many more subtle forms of racism
than those of open hostility or posts on Facebook about “being proud to be
white.” Indifference, indignation, and
resentment are the more insidious of them. If you are not working to at least
get to the root of the problem, regardless of political views, then you are a
dinosaur and are destined for extinction.
Your last throes of relevance will be angry and hateful and ugly. But you’ll go away, banished to the fringes
along with people who still believe in slavery.
Because when someone says to Mo, “but they’re white,” she says,
“So?”
I realize some of you might be saying, “Damn, Welch, I
just wanted to read a funny post about your kids, not a dissertation on
race.” Well, I assure you, this blog
will not become some platform of social justice. I have not become some crazy person who
thinks that just because he has a couple of black kids in his house he needs to
start a revolution. That’s just dorky
and embarrassing. But I got out what I
wanted to say, for better or worse. And the
main thing I want you to understand is that my views will continue to change
and flow, because I’m trying my damndest to grow. I’m trying desperately not to be so stuck in
my ways and my beliefs that I too become a dinosaur. I’ll keep learning more, listening more, and
trying harder to be the person and father the girls deserve. Because I love these kids. So much.
From our frustration and pain of not being able to have our own we found
in these girls our purpose. And they deserve to expect the same out of
life and this amazing country as I do.